Is it just me, or is Halloween a hotter topic of debate among Christians this year? I am seeing more posts about it online than I ever have before. I am seeing godly, well-intentioned people on both sides of the argument, and I'll say up front that it is not my place to demonize anyone (pun intended!). However, I have also seen cruel and legalistic posts, particularly from the pro-Halloween crowd, almost implying that those who chose not to celebrate it are spiritually immature and that celebrating it somehow makes you more godly. I disagree with the stance that what one does with Halloween--pro or con--is a mark of godliness. Godliness is much deeper than that. But all that aside, what do I believe about Halloween? More importantly, what does the Bible teach?
First, we need to separate fact from fiction. In short, Halloween began as the ancient Celtic festival Samhain, later blended with Christian observances like All Hallows' Eve, and eventually evolved into modern celebrations of jack-o'-lanterns, consumes, and trick-or-treating. Samhain celebrated the harvest. Sounds innocent enough. However, the Celts who observed this festival believed that on October 31, the spirits of the dead were allowed to return to earth, and they wore costumes and lit bonfires to protect themselves. As Christianity spread into Celtic regions, people blended Christian traditions with their pagan practices. Pope Gregory III moved All Saint's Day to November 1, making October 31 All Hallow's Eve, eventually shortened to Halloween. Like many of our other customs, Halloween is a blend of pagan and misinformed Christian practices. Celebrating Christ's birth on December 25 has a similar beginning of blending pagan celebrations and Christiaity, but Christmas is viewed much differently than Halloween. I will briefly address that later.
It should be noted that very few people who celebrate Halloween actually believe they're hiding from ghosts, or that they think the dead walk the earth. For most, it is a day of dressing up and getting candy. For a lot of years, people, many Christians included, treated it as harmless. I remember when I was three years old, our church had an actual haunted house (this was the early 80s, so I guess no one got the memo that Halloween was frowned-upon!). The teenagers of the church dressed up as scary ghosts and jumped out and scared the little kids. I remember being tiny, and being terrified they would pull all my teeth out (I'm not sure why I drew the conclusion they wanted to do that!).
I grew up in a Christian family, a close-knit neighborhood, and church community, and my parents let me trick-or-treat. We weren't allowed to dress up as witches or anything evil, but we wore fun costumes and got candy. Different years, I dressed up as a princess, a nurse, a bunny, a gypsy, an angel, and a 50s girl. My siblings and I would go door to door with our neighbor friends. One of the moms always went with us. Our parents would go through our candy when we got home to make sure it was safe. I didn't realize until I was 30 or so that they really thought it was all safe, but pretended to think some pieces weren't safe so that they could take them from us and eat them themselves! Those days were a blast. I have some fun memories. Both then and now, many Christians viewed and continue to view Halloween as harmless fun. Is it? Do I still believe that? Any why is Halloween being debated, while Christmas is largely enjoyed by Christians without the conflict?
I now feel uneasy about Halloween, not so much because of how it started (after all, most people aren't celebrating Samhain), but for the emphasis. I'll explain.
I said I'd return to Christmas, so lets use it as a comparison. A person can celebrate Christmas without focusing on Jesus, and they still have jolliness, presents, fun, and cheer. That isn't the true meaning, but it's lighthearted. Bright colors, lights, singing, presents, and visiting family are not evil activities. And for Christians, those things are the backdrop of honoring the birth of Jesus as the Savior who would come and die for our sins. It is a day of remembering God keeping His promise to send a Savior, even though it is very unlikely Jesus' actual birthday would have been December 25th. Besides that, there are a small amount of Christians who don't observe Christmas, but the debate isn't nearly as strong or polarizing as Halloween.
Halloween, on the other hand, is dark, focused on death, and making light of evil. I remember for a while, the trend was for kids to dress up in a normal costume (a cheerleader, a king, etc.) and then put a grotesque scar on their forehead to represent death, so they're a dead version of whatever they dressed up as. That is disgusting to play around with death. Death is a permanent thing, and Bible calls it our enemy (First Corinthians 15:26). Jesus conquered death--took the sting out of it (First Corinthians 15:55-56). Is death something Christians should play around with?
Beyond death itself, let's talk about witches and ghosts. Second Corinthians 5:8 says clearly that to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord (for believers). Unbelievers at death go to Hades, a place of torment, until they one day face the Great White Throne judgment and are cast into the lake of fire (Luke 16:19-31, Revelation 20:11-15). No deceased human, believer or unbeliever, is to be contacted. The Bible very clearly forbids contacting the dead (Deuteronomy 18:10-12, Leviticus 19:31, Leviticus 20:6, Isaiah 8:19, First Samuel 28). Witchcraft is also forbidden, and was punishable by death Exodus 22:18, Leviticus 20:27, as well as some of the previous scriptures mentioned about contacting the dead). Making light of things God has forbidden isn't something we as Christians should be condoning. I can't stand going to stores in October with disgusting decorations with gross-looking witches and horror.
As Christians, we are told to keep our mind on what is above (Colossians 3:2). We are to meditate on things that are true, honorable, righteous, pure and lovely (Philippians 4:8). We are to be the salt of the earth and light of the world (Matthew 5:13-16). How can we expect to be that when we're celebrating death, witches, and ghosts, things that are clearly not of God? Ephesians 5:17 says, Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them.
Spiritual warfare is real. Angels and demons are real. There is a battle going on around us all the time. Ephesians 6 tells us to be strong in the Lord, to put on His armor, and recognize our enemy isn't another person, but Satan and his followers. I don't want to be invited in something that makes thos very real battle out to be a joke.
That is my take on Halloween. There are godly people who see it as a ministry opportunity, having evangelistic outreaches at their churches for costumed youngsters. Others, like my parents in the 80s and early 90s, honestly see traditional trick-or-treating as harmless fun. October 31 is a day on the calendar. It isn't magic. It isn't evil. It's what you do with it.
A lot of the posts I've seen lately mock people who don't celebrate Halloween, making us out to be legalistic at best, insane at worst. Leave people to their convictions. If you believe it isn't wrong to celebrate it, then celebrate it without ripping people apart ir making fun of their conckusions (or strawman you think are their conclusions, which is really what most of these posts are).
I am not anyone else's conscience. No one is my enemy over this issue. Do as God has led you and your family. In all things give glory to God.






















